THE 50 BEST Pizza Restaurants near Natrona Heights, PA - 2024 Restaurantji (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“A&B Pizza provides excellent service and delicious food. They are accommodating and helpful, even providing plates and napkins if needed. Their signature thin crust pizza, half pepperoni and half sausage, is a standout, with customers raving about its saucy and cheesy goodness. The family-friendly atmosphere and kind staff, including the welcoming older gentleman behind the counter, make it a great spot for families and a long-time local favorite.“

Customers` Favorites

“Capri Pizza J&S Pizza II is a local favorite that consistently serves great food, including fresh baked bread and a delicious Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo. The friendly staff and owners provide attentive service, creating a welcoming family atmosphere. Enjoy excellent meals, like the chicken with red pepper sauce, at a good price.“

Customers` Favorites

“Anthony's Pizza, located inside a BP gas station, offers surprising quality pizza. The staff is known for their friendliness and helpfulness, often offering a variety of toppings and local treats. The pizza features a desirable amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings, with a commendable crust. It is a convenient location for a quick, satisfying bite, whether you're looking for a single slice or a whole pie. Many appreciate the fast service and welcoming atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for weary travelers or locals seeking a delicious meal.“

Customers` Favorites

“Pizza Hut is a nostalgic gem, keeping the dine-in experience alive. The fantastic waitress, Carol, makes the visit joyful and positive, ensuring everyone is accommodated without being pushy. The Taco Pizza, a blast from the past, is a must-try with bean paste on a crispy crust topped with lettuce, tomato, and cheddar. The service received from Carol is unparalleled, making it the best service in a decade. She goes above and beyond, interacting with kids and treating customers like family. The heartfelt service and delicious pizza make for a memorable dining experience. Bring back the pizza buffet for more unforgettable afternoons!“

Customers` Favorites

“Phillippi's Family Dining offers great food at good prices, with dishes like burgers, pizza, and salads that everyone enjoys. The birdville pie is a favorite, a unique blend of sauce and cheese similar to Chicago deep dish. Recent improvements in their pizza recipe have made it the best ever ordered from Phillippi's, with a delicious bite that customers hope will continue.“

Customers` Favorites

“J & S Pizza is a consistently great destination for food and service. The staff, including the counter server, are friendly and helpful. The food is excellent, with standouts including great pepperoni rolls, Italian hoagies, and a unique chicken salad with a meat and cheese roll-up. The restaurant also offers wings and thick crust pizza. With easy parking, a kid-friendly menu, and wheelchair accessibility, J & S Pizza is a welcoming spot for all.“

Customers` Favorites

“Capri Pizza Restaurant is a family favorite that consistently delivers authentic, flavorful, and pleasing meals. The food is some of the best Italian in Pittsburgh, with standout dishes like gnocchi with blush sauce and T-bone steak, both cooked to perfection. The restaurant offers generous portions with many sides, including fresh bread. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, with friendly staff and owners who attend to every need.“

Customers` Favorites

“Bob's Sub offers a welcoming atmosphere, big parking lot, and kid-friendly options like the freshman sandwiches. The restaurant serves great rolls and generous amounts of mayonnaise. Their steak and cheese sub is a standout, with high-quality ingredients and perfect flavor balance. With excellent customer service, Bob's Sub is a top-notch spot for a satisfying and enjoyable meal.“

Customers` Favorites

“Gus Franco's Pizza is a must-visit spot known for its excellent thin-crust pizzas. Customers praise the wood-fired pies with nice crust, cheese, and toppings. Despite some wait times, the tasty food is definitely worth it. The staff is friendly and welcoming, making the dining experience even better. With good prices and great quality, this place has become a new favorite for many pizza lovers. Don't miss out on trying their signature pies!“

Customers` Favorites

“Della Sala's Pizza in Verona is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers. With a rich family history behind their exceptional recipes, they serve up quality ingredients with a touch of love and consistency. The light and crispy dough perfectly complements the tasty toppings. Known for their hot sausage, this place offers great flavor at a reasonable price. A beloved spot for generations, it's a Penn Hills staple cherished by many for its delicious pizza and welcoming atmosphere.“

Customers` Favorites

“Frankstown Wood-Fired Pizza is a cozy, family-run establishment that serves some of the best pizzas in the Pittsburgh area. Their wood-fired oven takes center stage, producing delicious, fresh pizzas with high-quality ingredients. The margarita pizza is a popular favorite, and their fresh-baked bread is phenomenal. The owners and workers are kind and dedicated to their craft, making every bite a delight. With a variety of menu items, including hoagies, anti-pasta, and wedding soup, there's something for everyone. This hidden gem is well worth a visit, and its loyal customers can't recommend it enough.“

Customers` Favorites

“Somma Pizza & Sports Bar is a long-time favorite spot with consistently great food and friendly staff. The inviting atmosphere, affordable prices, and delicious salad and pizza make it a must-try. Families will appreciate the game room for kids. Mama Somma adds a delightful touch to the experience.“

Customers` Favorites

“Common Oven Pizza Co. is a local favorite that serves a variety of delicious dishes. Their menu features a range of options, including specialty pizzas, such as the Ricotta Arugula pizza, which is a standout favorite. They also offer a meatball sub and grilled cheese with roasted tomatoes. House-made mozzarella and fresh-baked focaccia are additional highlights. The pizza is wood-fired and cooked to perfection. With a focus on using high-quality ingredients, Common Oven Pizza Co. is a great spot for a meal or a snack.“

Customers` Favorites

“Round The Corner Eatery & Pizzeria offers a delightful dining experience with its exceptionally delicious food. The Hot Sausage Hoagie, garden salad with homemade Italian dressing, and the gigantic brownie are standouts. The pizza, especially the buffalo chicken and pierogi varieties, as well as the fried mushrooms and bacon cheeseburger, are all consistently amazing. The friendly and efficient service complements the fresh and very good food, making this a local favorite.“

Customers` Favorites

“Gino Brothers Pizzeria & Bar is a casual and welcoming spot, known for its friendly and attentive bartenders and servers. The atmosphere is lively, with games on TV and specials to enjoy. The food is always hot and reasonably priced. A must-try is the pepperoni rolls. With easy parking and a relaxed vibe, this local favorite is a great place to grab a drink and some good food.“

Customers` Favorites

“Perry Di Pizza Man's is a local family favorite for good pizza, hoagies, wings, and Stromboli. The owner's dedication and skill shine through in the perfectly made food. The crew in the kitchen and behind the counter are amazing, making the experience even better. With excellent pizza, chicken wings, and hoagies, this place is highly recommended for pick up or delivery. The large parking lot and wheelchair accessibility make it convenient for all customers. If you're looking for honest and plentiful toppings on your pizza or a top-notch hoagie, Perry Di Pizza Man's is the place to go.“

Customers` Favorites

“homemade good quality food“

Customers` Favorites

“Handlebar Cafe is a restaurant known for its delicious food and fun atmosphere. The steak and cheese hoagie and Chicago deep-dish pizza are standouts, with particularly tender meat and crunchy bread in the sandwich. The pizza is highly regarded, even compared to Chicago-style pizzas. The restaurant offers local beers, a variety of wines, and craft co*cktails. The staff is friendly and the location is clean, although there is only one toilet in the ladies' room. Some dishes, like the Alfredo, receive mixed reviews, with concerns about the quality of chicken used. Nonetheless, many customers, including this reviewer, enjoy their meals and the welcoming environment enough to plan return visits.“

Customers` Favorites

“LaScola's Pizzeria is a hidden gem that serves high-quality pizzas. Their standard pizza with two toppings features good cheese, a sweet sauce, and great pizza dough. Prices are fair and the experience is worth the drive. The pizza is crisp, soft, and fresh tasting with yum cheesy goodness. Other dishes, such as the Buffalo Chicken and BBQ Chicken pizzas, are also incredible.“

Customers` Favorites

“Lelulo's Pizzeria has received high praise from visitors, with many calling it one of the best pizza places they've been to. The restaurant, located outside of Pittsburgh, is known for its delicious pizza and friendly staff. One popular pizza is the meat lovers, while the "sweet sauce" pizza has also been highly recommended. The pizzeria also offers a traditional sauce and other menu items such as fried meatballs, garlic knots, and Italian hoagies. The crust was specifically noted for its exceptional taste. Overall, Lelulo's Pizzeria is considered a must-visit destination for pizza lovers.“

Customers` Favorites

“Pizza Hut is a reliable choice with friendly staff and good food, despite being a bit pricey due to company policies. The restaurant offers a consistent experience with well-presented dishes and a cozy atmosphere, making it a favorite for many customers. However, some issues were noted with the call-in ordering system leading to confusion, suggesting it might be easier to just order in-store.“

Customers` Favorites

“Stello's Pizzeria is a restaurant known for its delicious pizza, offering both thin and thick (Sicilian) styles. The restaurant has received praise for its friendly staff, high-quality ingredients, and accommodating vegetarian options, such as cheese pizza and various vegetable toppings. Customers have expressed their delight with the restaurant's service, timeliness, and the welcoming attitude of the owners. Some have even claimed it to be the best pizza they've ever had, making it a recommended spot for pizza lovers visiting Pittsburgh.“

Customers` Favorites

“Vocelli Pizza is a highly recommended restaurant that offers delicious pizza, fresh and hot upon delivery. The restaurant goes above and beyond to make special requests, such as making an 18 out of pepperoni for a birthday party and writing "Happy Birthday" on the boxes. The staff is helpful and accommodating, thinking through orders and specials to ensure a perfect delivery. The restaurant delivers quickly, even to areas far out, and offers a wide variety of menu items, including hoagies, salads, and rolls. The pizza always looks and tastes perfect, making it a favorite among customers.“

Customers` Favorites

“Leechburg Pizza Company offers great pizza with fantastic crust, generous portions, and delicious toppings. Despite the limited operating hours, guests appreciate the variety of options available, such as different sauce choices and ample toppings on the Meat pizza. The hoagies are also a hit, with huge and tasty meatballs. Customers love the crispy pepperoni and the loaded steak salad. The evolving menu keeps things interesting, making it a go-to spot for tasty food delivered straight to your door.“

Customers` Favorites

“Pizza Moena is a restaurant that offers delicious food and convenient delivery service, particularly for those who are disabled. The chicken bacon ranch hoagie and pepperoni pizza are popular choices, and their basic cheese pizza with extra sauce and buffalo sauce is highly recommended. The buffalo sauce is said to taste homemade, setting it apart from other pizza places that use pre-made sauces. The foreign staff members are friendly and make the pizza with care. The prices are reasonable compared to other pizza spots. Overall, Pizza Moena is a great option for those looking for delicious pizza and good value.“

Customers` Favorites

“Fox's Pizza Den is known for their delicious BAMBINO pizza, a quick and cheap lunch option. Customers love their Monday and Tuesday specials, making it a favorite spot for families. However, some have experienced issues with orders being incorrect and portion sizes.“

Customers` Favorites

“Fox's Pizza Den is a restaurant known for its amazing food and exceptional customer service. The staff is kind, apologetic, and quick to remedy any issues. They offer lunch specials and have long-term employees, indicating a positive work culture. The restaurant recently improved the taste of their bread, much to the delight of their customers. It is a kid-friendly place with ample parking right in front of the door.“

Customers` Favorites

“Mercurio’s O’Hara offers wonderful pizza with light, flavorful crust and fresh toppings. The Sicilian style pizza is a must-try, more filling than the traditional kind. The Pasta is equally delicious. Great spot after a movie at Waterworks, with friendly and efficient service. Favorite pizzas include Pizza Del Re and Margharita Con Buffalo.“

Customers` Favorites

“Riviera Pizza and Pasta in Lower Burrell is a go-to spot for many locals. Known for their delicious pizza and hoagies, they also serve tasty wings, fries, and spaghetti with meatballs. Customers appreciate the friendly service and the fact that they always cut their pizzas all the way through. With a variety of options available, including salads and garlic bread, Riviera Pizza and Pasta is a solid choice, especially for those looking for late-night dining in the area.“

Customers` Favorites

“Tony's Pizza Cafe is a wonderful Italian restaurant with great food and exceptional service. Customers can enjoy a variety of dishes, from hot Italian hoagies and lasagna to delicious pizza. The owner is known for his kindness and attentiveness to customers, often remembered regulars and going the extra mile to make their experience pleasant. The restaurant offers ample parking and a cozy atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for families and groups. Overall, Tony's Pizza Cafe is a highly recommended dining destination, known for its delicious food and top-notch customer service.“

“Experience a taste of nostalgia at Siciliano's Pizzeria, where the flavors of the 1960s and 70s come alive in their homemade pizzas and capicola hoagies. Travel for hours just for a meal here, as the Italian hoagies and broccoli salad are described as the best ever eaten. This family-run Pittsburgh gem not only serves up the very best pizza but also offers a variety of hot hoagies like steak and cheese, meatball, and Italian, as well as deli items like chicken salad and potato salad. Take some fresh rolls or croissants home, along with some fresh meat and cheese, and enjoy a pop, cappuccino, or ice cream bar from this friendly and wonderful establishment. Become a regular customer and savor the taste of authentic, homemade goodness.“

“The individual cheese puzzas“

“pretty good pizza and hoagies.“

Customers` Favorites

“Leone's Pizza is a renowned establishment known for its exceptional pizza offerings. The restaurant offers a delightful thin-crust pizza with a satisfying crispiness, complemented by a range of toppings, including the popular chicken parmesan and a Sicilian-style pizza with pepperoni and banana peppers. Customers praise the restaurant's attentive service, fresh and hot deliveries, and the overall quality of the menu, making it a local favorite in Oakmont.“

Customers` Favorites

“Pasquale's Pizzeria is a local favorite with great pizza and reliable delivery service by their own delivery person. The food is usually delicious and arrives hot, with friendly and knowledgeable staff to assist with orders. While some minor mishaps have occurred in the past, overall, Pasquale's Pizzeria is a go-to spot for tasty food and pleasant service.“

Customers` Favorites

“P&M Pizza is a cozy eatery that serves up delicious American-style pizza and more. Upon entering, customers are greeted by friendly staff, including a lovely bartender who is happy to assist with orders. The restaurant offers a variety of options, including the popular P&M thin crust pizza, as well as Italian Salads and other tasty treats. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with a welcoming vibe that makes guests feel right at home. In addition to its great food and service, P&M Pizza is also wheelchair accessible and offers a convenient takeout option. With its reasonable prices and generous portions, this hidden gem is a must-visit for anyone looking for a satisfying meal.“

Customers` Favorites

“Veltre's Pizza is a local favorite, known for its exceptional pizza and diverse menu offerings. The pizza is praised for its fresh, non-greasy crust and flavorful sauce, making it a top choice for pizza enthusiasts. In addition to the delectable pizza, the restaurant also offers delicious pasta dishes and Italian calzones that have received high praise from customers. While delivery may not be available, the consistently great food and friendly service keep customers coming back time and time again.“

Customers` Favorites

“Pizza Roma is a family-friendly restaurant that offers delectable pizza and wings. The mild wings are a standout, with a flavorful kick that is not typical of mild wings. The pizza is also highly praised, with one customer finding a favorite they had missed from a closed-down establishment. The service is friendly, adding to the homely atmosphere. While the decor could use some updating, the overall dining experience is excellent.“

Customers` Favorites

“Papa Johns Pizza is known for its polite and helpful staff. The restaurant serves a wide range of pizzas, including pepperoni pizza, and offers a variety of sides, such as breadsticks. The pizza is cooked perfectly, and the staff is always quick and efficient.“

“Fox's Pizza Den receives mixed reviews. Some customers find the pizza's crust to taste like frozen pizza, while others enjoy its unique flavor. The staff is noted for being friendly and courteous. The restaurant offers delivery, with hot and fresh food. The menu, reminiscent of the '80s, includes a variety of options, except for pre-fried wing dings, which may not appeal to all. Overall, Fox's Pizza Den provides a nostalgic dining experience.“

Customers` Favorites

“Domino's Pizza is a reliable and compassionate eatery that consistently delivers fresh and well-prepared meals. The staff is professional, kind, and willing to resolve any issues that may arise. The pizzas are generously topped and feature amazing bread twists. While mistakes can happen, the team at Domino's is quick to make it right. With a focus on customer satisfaction, this Domino's location is a repeat customer favorite.“

Customers` Favorites

“Wow... Ok in my line of work I get to eat some good food. But this place is amazing. Ordered a pizza done just perfect I mean beautiful and taste amazing. But what blew my mind was the wing dings my guys are old fashioned cooked just right and served on a double brown paper bag. So primetime my hat is off to you. Keep killing it??“

Customers` Favorites

“Fox's Pizza Den in Penn Hills is known for its good pizza delivery and crispy, tender wings with high-quality meat. The cheesy bread is a popular choice, although some customers have found it to be light on cheese. There have been a few issues with orders being incorrect, possibly due to the noisy environment of the open kitchen and TV. The service is generally friendly and prompt. The restaurant is a popular choice for wings and delivery or pick-up orders.“

“Strange Roots Experimental Ales offers an impressive selection of funky beers, including Brett/wild/mixed fermentation brews. The taproom features a welcoming atmosphere, friendly and helpful staff, and solid food. The area may be a little depressed, but the "downtown" area is quaint. The pizza is a highlight, and the Jenny cream ale is a favorite among regulars. With a cool name and great beers, Strange Roots is a must-visit spot.“

Customers` Favorites

“Lock 5 Tavern offers consistently good food, including great burgers and daily specials, in a recently updated atmosphere. Friendly bartenders serve delicious meals, from regular bar food to a weekly changing menu. The talented chef impresses with every dish, including fantastic pasta Bolognese and delicious soups, all at a reasonable price.“

Customers` Favorites

“Franco's Pizza is a beloved institution in Plum, serving the community for many years. They offer a variety of delicious options, including their signature soft-style crust pizza with NY-style sauce, hoagies, and fries. The menu also features vegetarian options like the Vegetarian hoagie and pizza. With fast delivery and decent service, Franco's is a staple for many families, offering great value and quality food that's always fresh and hot.“

Customers` Favorites

“Tnt Dynamite Pizza & Hoagies offers a diverse menu, including the beloved buffalo chicken pizza and delectable chicken tenders with fresh cut fries. While some customers praise the amazing flavor and top-notch quality, others express concerns about inconsistent slicing and a sometimes-mushy, greasy center. The restaurant's staff is described as friendly, and the ambiance is enhanced by the occasional Johnny Cash soundtrack.“

Customers` Favorites

“Domino's Pizza offers excellent customer service, with orders always being correct and ready on time. One customer shared how the driver went above and beyond to rectify a mistake promptly. Another customer praised the efficient and accurate service, vouching to return. A third customer appreciated the quality food and fast service compared to the previous pizzeria in the area. Overall, this Domino's branch stands out for its exceptional customer service and delicious pizzas.“

Customers` Favorites

“Mac Kenzie's Pub offers an exceptional dining experience with its delectable wings, white pizza, hot pepper cheese balls, and fried cauliflower. Customers can enjoy their meals indoors or on the outdoor terrace, which provides beautiful views. The restaurant is consistently rated as the best place to get pizza in the local area.“